"You're an interesting man, Mr. Scamander. Just like
your suitcase, I think there's more to you than meets the eye."
I would call myself a fan of Harry Potter. I enjoy the films to varying degrees with them being more of a nostalgia trip for me than being on any kind of favourites list. The books though, all incredibly solid. Not going to lie I was nervous at the very idea of this new trilogy (as it was originally announced to be). I knew it wasn’t going to be long after the Harry Potter series ended we would see Warner Bros. knocking on JK’s door holding a big sack of money asking her to write or for permission to write a brand new series of films. Especially with Warner Bros. in a current state of confusion and uncertainty. You must remember that Harry Potter ended very soon after Christopher Nolan finished his Dark Knight Trilogy, Warner Bros. had to do something.
While watching I found myself being dazzled and excited within the first ten to twenty minutes and I decided I wasn’t going to give the film a pass purely because it did an excellent job of sweeping me back into this universe. I'd put this down to to David Yate's direction, as much as it was a very safe bet having him return to direct its payed off in terms of his visual style being very reminiscent of the his other films.
While yes you do feel like you’re back in this world I didn’t find many of the characters particularly engrossing or fascinating. In Harry Potter the film was set in the Wizarding World with the Muggle World being sidelined totally, obviously this is what we want. I wouldn’t say it’s the complete opposite here but I can say the film spends way too long on New York Muggle politics.
Eddie Redmayne whom I’ve never found amazingly compelling as an actor was great as this bumbling bloke from England. There wasn’t a lot of ‘fish out of water’ type humour as I thought there would be from his character and I appreciated that. He was an interesting character to follow through the story and I liked that, Dave Fogler served as the "audience's eyes" character and surprisingly it didn’t irritate me entirely, his and Redmayne’s characters were definitely my favourite parts of the film, particularly shining in one scene inside the briefcase, which I would have liked to have been elaborated on more. Everyone else in the film I would call serviceable, many great actors felt wasted.
Its probably the thick and tone shifting plot that dragged the film down for me. The film’s called Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, to be honest I think would have preferred a film with Newt going on a wacky adventure to capture some magical creatures. Yes we do get some of that in this film but much of it is side lined by American Magical Politics, American Muggle Politics and Colin Farrell’s character’s convoluted plan. All these things didn’t always mesh particularly well and it’s a shame.
The thing that more or less pushed me over the edge concerning the film would probably considered a spoiler so heres your warning.
Someone has a cameo at the end and it serves the story in no way and felt totally out of place. Depp's performance and look did not match the rest of the film aesthetically. Before it happened (as Graves was captured) I genuinely thought to myself “ok whats the dumbest thing they could do here” and giving us an apparent twist with Graves turning out to be Grindelwald was it. I honestly have no idea why they did it, I feel like Graves should have simply been a follower of Grindelwald.
Actually to be honest I wouldn’t have had a problem with it if it wasn’t Johnny Depp, his face was just too well known and he totally took me out of the film as he always does. I don’t want to see four Johnny Depp Fantastic Beasts films. Warner Bros. couldn’t control Jared Leto as the Joker I have no doubt they won’t be able to control Depp.
To conclude though if you're looking for a fun and exciting film set in a fantasy world this film will probably satisfy you. If you're a Harry Potter purist it would grind you in places and if you're indifferent towards the whole Harry Potter thing this isn't the film that's going to change your mind.
If you enjoyed this written review and would like to hear more from me (quite literally) I do a weekly podcast where I talk films/TV with another guy who also talks film/TV.
https://soundcloud.com/blanketbros
Follow me on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/MaxBezant